Ask an Atheist with Sam Mulvey

We're done trying, but the door is still open.

We’ve now spent a year trying to get someone in the 9/11 Truth movement to be on the show and have a fair discussion of the facts and evidence that could lead to questioning the official narrative.   No one we’ve contacted has stepped up to the plate .  Instead, we’re seeing people creep into our YouTube channel well after the episode airs, and post-show calls questioning how we handled the episode.

We don’t care.  No one has been willing to stand with their beliefs on a live episode, with previously agreed to rules to insure a fair conversation.  As far as I’m concerned, that makes those beliefs suspect.

The Truthers have had the opportunity to be on our show, in front of a microphone, to make sure we get it right.   Monday morning quarterbacking is not interesting.   If you want to ensure we get it right, contact us and we’ll have you on for the debate.

We won’t hold your hand, we won’t give you the whole hour, and we won’t prevent people from asking you questions.   But we will work to be fair.

About the Author: Sam Mulvey

Sam Mulvey is a producer and the technical brain behind Ask an Atheist. He is a collector of vinegar varieties, vintage computers, antique radios, and propaganda.

Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Like I told Case: I may have to study up on the Truth movement just so he has someone to debate.

Mike Nam

I think it was pointed out that when the first truss failed you can make out the penthouse structures on the roof collapsing from one side to the other. Thus, it’s a mistake to say the building fell in a single, unified piece as the that last caller was suggesting.


I had an old friend post a building 7 conspiracy video to facebook on 9/11. It was good to see how many people responded that it was nonsense. The “undeniable truth” was was so wholly unamazing that my 9th grader came up with the same likely scenario that I did. If you haven’t seen it, there is a “proof” video where the BBC is anouncing WTC 7 has collapsed, yet in the background you can make out WTC 7 still standing. I find it amzing that someone of average intellect could not see the likely reason (or reasons) this could… Read more »


Maybe you should tell the Truthers there will be punch and pie if they come. As we learned in South Park, more people will come if they think there’s punch and pie.


Well then just tell them it’s Free Waffles for Truthers Day and engage them in some friendly conversation while you accidentally leave the microphones on.


I used to be an official story supporter until some yrs ago i came across these amongst other things tht troubled me n i want u to tell me wht to make of those. passport of hijacker “magically” recovered whilst whole plane INC BLACK BOXES were demolished, larry silverstein insuring of wtc 7 just weeks be4 911 n him SURPISINGLY GETTING an appointment with the dermatologist on the morning of 911(watch?v=HEb4vxK72TE&list=F­L9EyEXZUdmjHXd-ZVP4FPuw&index=­5). note also tht it was confirmed tht when Silverstein said “pull” there WERE NO FIREMEN in there so he cldnt have meant tht, there being wargames practicing a terror… Read more »

[…] I get on to writing more important things, I thought I would highlight a comment we got on our blog recently.   This is something I […]

Jeremiah Hanley

they know your part of The Man…that’s why

Charlie R Frey

“…you’re gatekeepers, maaaaaaaaaaaan!”

Charlie R Frey

A fee years ago, Opie & Anthony (xm) were confronted by truthers:

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x